Comparative analysis, or what is better to buy - Tefal or Philips steam generator

Steam generators - devices for ironing linen, clothes and other textiles from various fabrics and removing stains and dirt from them with steam.

They are produced by many well-known home appliance manufacturers, including Tefal and Philips. The products of both of these brands are reliable, which makes it difficult for consumers to choose them.

Let's try to figure out which is better to choose - a steam generator Tefal or Phillips.

Differences between Philips and Tefal

According to research by Roskachestvo, conducted in conjunction with the authoritative expert organization ICRT, Philips steam generators are leaders in ironing quality, and Tefal models are distinguished by the largest amount of steam produced per unit of time.

Along with Tefal and Philips 3 more well-known brands took part in the study, in total 40 models were tested... Of these, in terms of ironing quality, all three first places were taken by Philips steam generators (the leader is GC9640 / 60).

Analogues from Tefal, in terms of their ability to iron polyester and cotton fabrics, as well as denim, were inferior to almost all Philips models, although they surpassed other competitors.

A completely different picture was established by the power of vaporization... According to this criterion, the first place is taken by the model GV9560E0 Pro Express Ultimate Care from Tefal.

In production

Philips steam generators, presented on the Russian market, are mostly produced at the enterprises of this brand operating in China, Indonesia or the Netherlands. In the Russian Federation, the assembly of such products is not carried out.

In the lineup

The Philips brand offers steam generators in different capacities and with different tank sizes. They also differ in the coating of the sole. The Tefal models have the same differences.

One of the most expensive Tefal models - GV8960 - easily iron any fabric... Steam pressure 6 bar, with steam shock - 340 g / min.

GV 7620 (about 10,000 rubles) produces steam with a maximum pressure of 5 bar. The GV7310 (about 8500-8800 rubles) has the same figure of 4.5 bar. It is good for ironing cotton fabrics.

The Philips model GC 9222 with a maximum steam pressure of 6 bar provides fast and high-quality ironing.

Great choice - Philips HI5914... It is lightweight, fits comfortably in the hand and has an attractive design. The steam pressure reaches 5 bar.The Smart Calc-Clean system is used to remind you to descale.

In the price

The cost of models with approximately the same performance differs from both brands. The Philips variants are slightly more expensive.

At the same time, models from Philips are more popular. This is evidenced by ratings on Yandex.Market.

In service

Household appliances from Tefal and Philips are both reliable, but not insured against breakdowns. Tefal products have a lifespan of 2 years from the date of retail sale or manufacture, if it is not possible to determine when the sale was made.

The warranty does not cover cases when the problem arose due to:

• using the wrong type of water
• scale that was not removed according to the instructions;
• mechanical damage to the steam generator or its overload;
• inconsistencies in the frequency and voltage of electric current, etc.

Philips has a fairly extensive network of authorized service centers in the Russian Federation. There are more than 500 of them in the capital. There are service centers of the Tefal brand in most regions of the Russian Federation. There are more than 150 of them in the capital alone.

Pros and cons

For comparison, let's choose two popular models of both brands - Philips GC4850 and Tefal FV5375... Their performance characteristics are quite similar.

Both steam generators have sprinklers, descaling systems, etc. Judging by consumer reviews, both steam generators provide excellent ironing care. The devices glide perfectly on the fabric without catching or damaging.

The Philips model has a Steamglide Plus sole, while Tefal has an Autoclean Cathalys.

Autoclean Cathalys outsole is made of durilium... A thin layer of palladium is deposited on its surface.

As a result, when organic substances present on the fabric hit the sole, a chemical reaction occurs. Water and a small amount of carbon dioxide are released, which automatically cleans the surface.

The Steamglide Plus outsole on Philips models creates an air cushion over the fabric with holes of different shapes and sizes. Ironing occurs with virtually no contact between the sole and the fabric.

Of the advantages of Philips GC 4850, it should be noted:

• ergonomic design, thanks to which the steam generator is easy to use without getting tired of ironing;
• powerful steam to remove even the most difficult creases.

Tefal FV5375 is appreciated by consumers for:

• fast heating;
• clear work of the self-shutdown system.

On the last parameter Tefal bypasses Philips. This is where its benefits end.

Moreover, the list of consumer complaints about Tefal devices is quite long:

• the steam generator can hardly smooth even ordinary shirts;
• weak heating, not corresponding to that declared by the manufacturer, due to which, even for synthetics, you need to set the maximum heating temperature;
• not long enough cord;
• prolonged cooling;
• the possibility of stains on the fabric.

The last disadvantage, however, is associated with consumer non-compliance with the rules for operating steam generators.

Which one and when to choose?

For ironing, it is better to purchase Philips models... These perfectly smooth out any creases.

Tefal models are more versatile due to more powerful steam generation. They are also suitable for high-quality cleaning of premises.

Tefal is less suitable for ironing, as things remain somewhat damp and cannot be immediately put into the closet.

Let's sum up

Phillips steam generators are slightly more expensive than similar Tefal options.

The models of both TMs have proven their ability to withstand intensive use during "test drives". The choice of brand depends on the goals of the buyer.